Difference In the Districts: How Corpus Christi and Austin Prepare for a Mock Trial Against One Another

By: Caydenn Angeles
W.B. Ray High School
Austin, TX – When hosting the District Conference for Texas Youth and Government, the districts of Texas are divided into four separate conferences. In Texas’s state capital, Austin, one of these conferences is held between Austin itself and Corpus Christi, along with other cities.
The verdict of Harper Lin, a 31-year-old woman accused of murder, criminal conspiracy, and criminal solicitation against Cody Maddox, depended on Veterans Memorial High School from Corpus Christi, Texas, which stood as the prosecution, and Liberal Arts and Science Academy High School from Austin, Texas, which defended the accused woman. Through the observation of this specific mock trial, a question arose: Do different districts of Texas prepare and perform using different strategies?
The final verdict for this court trial was decided by the judge as not guilty. There were many factors that contributed to the verdict of this woman, but Liberal Arts and Science Academy High School stood out to me when defending their client. During the trial, the defense provided objections to the judge a significant amount more than the prosecution. Veterans Memorial made a great attempt to prosecute Lin but was unable to ask sufficient questions to witnesses in this trial overall. This is because, while the prosecution would try to ask a question towards the witnesses in this trial, the defense would continuously state, “Objection!” which would typically later be sustained by the judge.
After the verdict was announced, I proposed an interview with Diya Darshan, the lead attorney of this court case who has participated in this event for three years, with the intention to discover if these consecutive objections were a planned tactic or if it was a a happy coincidence that contributed to their success. “That wasn’t specifically planned, as there were many instances of a foundation not being laid properly for the witness to be questioned about that topic. This gave us an upper hand as they weren’t able to enter evidence for specific witnesses and receive crucial feedback,” Darshan responds. It was interesting to view the mindset lawyers must have when performing in a trial, as it seems like a nerve-racking job to possess. Darshan helped me formulate a clearer understanding of her process, as her “biggest strategy was to look at the judge and solely convince them only as it is their courtroom despite the pressure,” ignoring any sort of self- consciousness that would impact her performance.
Despite Harper Lin being found not guilty, Veterans Memorial High School still provided an exceptional performance that impressed me. Keane Wood, a witness for the prosecution, stated that it was Veterans Memorial High School’s “first time attending a conference of Youth and Government.” This was a factor of the trial I was unaware of during the observation oftheir mock trial, so discovering this unknown fact contributed to my curiosity within their methods of preparation. “Understanding the trial and making questions that would defend our accusations was our main focus in preparation,” Wood stated, “but we weren’t able to fully defend our points because the defense’s objections to our questions kept getting sustained.” Because the defense seemed very relaxed with their case, I then asked Wood if their confidence intimidated him to the point of affecting his performance. “Their confidence, along with their constant objections, was definitely intimidating for me, and it was hard to stay collected when I was under pressure as a witness.”
The differences between each school from the towns of Corpus Christi, Texas, and Austin, Texas within their level of preparation, expertise, and performance was profound. Liberal Arts and Science Academy High School maintained preparation, as they were experienced and knew how to format and defend their evidence. On the other hand, Veterans Memorial High School were not as confident within their abilities because of their low experience level and inability to ask questions that were necessary to succeed. Though, one thing schools had in common from both Corpus Christi, Texas, and Austin, Texas, was pressure. Acting as any member of a trial, whether you’re a lead attorney or witness, is required for your whole team to succeed. There is no doubt that even if certain districts have more expertise within mock trials, the pressure each Youth and Government member feels proves the care they have for this organization.










